Pie for Breakfast Review – Higher End Diner Fare in Oakland

Last Updated on August 6, 2020 by Angie

Disclaimer: Our site uses demographic data, email opt-ins, display advertising, and affiliate links. Please check out our Terms and Conditions. Pricing, operating hours, or menus may have changed since our initial visit and may not be reflected in subsequent updates. Please confirm these directly with any business or attraction prior to visiting.

In early 2020 the owners of Pie for Breakfast said they are merging their three restaurant concepts into one business. As such, this location may be in a state of flux. Please confirm if this one is open prior to your visit. We will update accordingly as we learn more.

Pie for Breakfast is a trendy diner in Oakland serving up creative diner fare and homemade pies.

The menu here goes beyond just the basic eggs and bacon staples and ventures deftly into steaks, kielbasa, quiches, biscuits and gravy, and a good selection of healthier vegetarian options as well.

Pie for Breakfast Serves Higher End Diner Fare

Pie for Breakfast Pittsburgh

We visited on a crowded weekday around lunchtime and took a seat at the bar to hasten our meal along. We perused the menu and basically wanted one of everything, so ordering was challenging.

Two things we knew we had to try: the house-made salt rising bread, and a slice of pie. We decided to order on opposite ends of the spectrum – Jeremy went with a steak and I went with the vegetarian tofu scramble.

Tofu Scramble at Pie for Breakfast

The tofu scramble was exceedingly delicious with incredibly creamy, fluffy, almost cheesy tasting tofu stuffed full of cremini mushrooms and kale. The scramble was supposed to be served with braised greens which sounded fantastic, but they were out so we decided on pickled beets instead.

And as if that wasn't enough food, the dish also came with rich and hardy black eyed peas and salt rising bread toast. The bread was sliced on the thicker side and had a fine crumb and a pleasant funky tang that complemented the homemade grape jelly served on the side (extra cost).

Minute Steak at Pie for Breakfast

Normally I would steer way the heck away from ordering steak at a diner, but the minute steak we had here was the real deal.

It was good quality meat (from a local-ish Saxonburg butcher) cooked super tender and juicy and bathed in herb butter. The steak came with our choice of two sides; we opted for mujadara and home fries. The home fries were well-seasoned big hunks of potatoes with a slightly crispy exterior, while the mujadara was an unexpectedly delightful savory mix of rice, lentils, and onions.

Pie is a Must, Naturally

Vinegar Pie

Now, let's talk about pie. As you might expect from the restaurant name, they have a full pie menu here with several selections that change daily. We had heard about the vinegar pie and knew we had to try something so unique – we were not disappointed!

The vinegar pie was a revelation with nicely browned, super thick and flaky crust cocooning the custardy, sugary, slightly tangy filling with a thick layer of caramelized sugar on top. If this pie is any indication, we need to return stat to try all of the other flavors.

Pie for Breakfast in Pittsburgh's Oakland Neighborhood

We didn't partake in the bar selection but if you're feeling so inclined they do offer beer, wine, coffee cocktails, and other brunch cocktails like mules and spritzes.

For us, Pie for Breakfast definitely lived up to the hype with elevated, home cooked diner food. Whatever you do, just be sure to save room for pie!

Pie for Breakfast is located at 200 N Craig Street in Oakland.

Looking for more breakfast options in Pittsburgh? Check out Pamela's, Cafe on Main, Johnny's Diner, or The Grand Concourse!

Leave a Comment